Top Prospects Dazzle at Combine, But Castoff QBs Offer Real Value
The 2026 NFL Draft class reshaped its perception with standout athleticism at the combine, while the quarterback market is set to focus on acquiring value over high-profile talent.
INDIANAPOLIS — The 2026 NFL Draft class came into the scouting combine under a cloud of skepticism. Then the top prospects took the field and delivered.
Elite athleticism on display this week has completely shifted the narrative. The combine workouts generated genuine buzz heading into the season. The class no longer feels like a disappointment.
The Real Story: A Quarterback Market Built on Value, Not Hype
Here's what matters most: The quarterback market this offseason will be defined by opportunity, not premium talent.
The draft class essentially has Heisman Trophy winner Fernando Mendoza—and that's it. Free agency is a different story. Aaron Rodgers, Malik Willis, Kyler Murray, Tua Tagovailoa, Kirk Cousins, and Geno Smith will all be available. Expect Willis to command the highest price at roughly $30 million per year, which is bargain-basement for a starting quarterback—though he has started just six NFL games.
But NFL executives are fixating on one word in Indianapolis: value.
Here's the paradox: These quarterbacks aren't castoffs because they're bad. Rodgers, Murray, Tua, Cousins, and Smith have all been productive recently—each was a top-10 QB at some point. They were overpaid, however, and those bloated contracts strangled their teams' ability to build supporting casts.
Now? Many have already banked $100 million-plus in their careers. They can afford to prioritize the best situation over the biggest paycheck. That creates an opening for smart front offices to land quality quarterback play at a fraction of market rate.
Consider the possibilities:
- Kyler Murray in Minnesota under coach Kevin O'Connell, distributing to Justin Jefferson, T.J. Hockenson, and Jordan Addison
- Geno Smith in Atlanta, the same role where he posted a top-5 passing season with Seattle, now throwing to Bijan Robinson, Drake London, and Kyle Pitts
Murray looked broken at $55 million in Arizona. Smith was a disaster in Las Vegas. Different teams, different systems, different supporting casts—suddenly both make sense at reasonable money.
"It's the offseason of the castoff quarterback. But there's value." — An optimistic QB-needy executive
11 Bold Predictions From Indianapolis
- Ohio State safety Caleb Downs will be the draft's best overall prospect—even as a non-premium position player. The GM who lands him sleeps easy.
- Fernando Mendoza goes first overall. (Obviously.)
- Notre Dame RB Jeremiyah Love stays inside the top 10. One scout told me Love is a better prospect than Ashton Jeanty, who went No. 6 last year and rushed for 975 yards and five touchdowns as a rookie.
- Ohio State LB Sonny Styles doesn't fall out of the top 10 either.
- Oregon safety Dillon Thieneman won't slip past No. 16.
- The Broncos trade up to grab Oregon tight end Kenyon Sadiq.
- A.J. Brown lands with the Patriots. Stefon Diggs does not.
- Running backs David Montgomery, Kenneth Walker III, Travis Etienne Jr., Rico Dowdle, Kenneth Gainwell, and Tyler Allgeier all get traded or signed. Destinations: Broncos, Chiefs, Texans, Giants, Ravens, Raiders.
- Malik Willis stays with Green Bay—not the Dolphins, despite Miami GM Jon-Eric Sullivan and coach Jeff Hafley's Packers ties.
- Anthony Richardson lands with the Eagles.
- The Bills trade up in Round 1 for a receiver.
The Workout Warriors Who Saved Their Draft Stock
Kenyon Sadiq (Oregon TE): The fastest tight end ever at the combine (4.39-second 40-yard dash), he measured at a true 6-foot-3 and exploded with a 43.5-inch vertical leap. Shorter for the position, yes, but his athleticism is remarkable.
Sonny Styles (Ohio State LB): His workout was so impressive that Ravens star Kyle Hamilton said he got "framemogged" in comparison. Styles might be the most complete athlete in this draft class.
Dillon Thieneman (Oregon safety): Pound-for-pound with Styles, Thieneman ran a 4.35-second 40-yard dash, jumped 41 inches vertically, and posted a 10-foot-5-inch broad jump. The film shows an elite safety and three-year starter. Absurd.
Jeremiyah Love (Notre Dame RB): His 4.36-second 40-yard dash matched Jahmyr Gibbs' 2023 combine time. But it's the movement skills in drills—not just running back drills but receiver drills too—that confirmed he won't slide. One scout's take: "Love is a better prospect than Ashton Jeanty."
The QB2 Problem: Garrett Nussmeier's Fading Stock
LSU's Garrett Nussmeier came into 2026 with serious hype. He returned to school specifically to win a national championship and secure a first-round pick. Instead, his draft stock is cratering.
Nussmeier helped LSU upset then-No. 4 Clemson to start the season and rode a four-game win streak. Then everything fell apart. A "torso injury" hampered him for most of the year, and season-ending blowouts to Texas A&M and Alabama exposed his limitations.
"Hopefully the next few weeks go really well for him and he can get back to where he should be — in the first round. All it takes is a couple teams saying, 'Let's look at the entirety of all the information and make the right decision.'" — Joe Sloan, former LSU OC
An AFC executive I spoke with was blunt: "He played well in 2024—not so great in 2025. His combine performance was OK overall. He did have a couple nice throws. Meetings will be important for him the rest of the spring, and pro day."
Nussmeier probably can't leapfrog Alabama's Ty Simpson as QB2. But he can still land on Day 2 as a team's developmental project—ideally with an organization that has proven success at the quarterback position.
Inside the Super Bowl: How Seattle Embarrassed Drake Maye
The Seahawks' Super Bowl victory exposed a critical weakness in Drake Maye's game: recognition of complex blitz packages.
Seattle's defensive master stroke centered on cornerback Devon Witherspoon. He blitzed seven times in the Super Bowl after blitzing just 19 times all regular season. He became the game's real MVP.
Here's how it worked:
The Seahawks exploited New England's two-by-one receiver sets. Every time, Witherspoon came from the two-receiver side out of the slot. Patriots OC Josh McDaniels couldn't adjust. The formation gave Seattle a Trojan Horse into New England's backfield on third down.
Witherspoon was an especially effective blitzer because he exploited how the Patriots' offensive line oversets toward the sideline, opening interior rushing lanes for a speedy 185-pound cornerback.
The Patriots knew it was coming—at least after the first time. But Maye couldn't recognize it, even with safety indicators standing over the blitzing cornerback.
"He got caught napping." — A source on Drake Maye
Maye's intellectual growth in 2026 was significant, but he wasn't ready for Seahawks coach Mike Macdonald, arguably football's smartest defensive mind.
Sean Payton Surrenders Play-Calling to Keep Offensive Coordinator
Denver Broncos coach Sean Payton ceded play-calling duties to offensive coordinator Davis Webb to retain him from poaching.
Multiple teams, including the Buffalo Bills, were recruiting Webb as their next offensive coordinator. Rather than lose his top voice, Payton made a rare concession at this stage of his career. Payton will contribute heavily to weekly game planning and weigh in during games, but Webb now owns the calls.
It's a stunning move for a tenured coach—a clear signal that Payton values Webb's future more than maintaining full control.
On another note: Payton regrets the play call in the AFC Championship loss to New England, not the decision itself. On fourth-and-1 from the 14-yard line, he dialed up play-action from backup Jarrett Stidham. No one was open. Interception. Game over.
The play call was indefensible. The fourth-down decision will fuel offseason debate.